Most of the unpaid home claims never got past the deductible
Insurance Commissioner Mike Yaworsky's office made every insurer report its Hurricane Isaias claims, and more than one in five home claims have closed with no payment. About half of those were for damage below the owner's hurricane deductible, by our count.
Why it matters: The hurricane deductible is the first check a Florida owner writes after a storm. On a home insured for $1 million, a 2% deductible is $20,000, by our arithmetic.
The story so far: Hurricane Isaias came ashore near Destin on Oct. 9 as a Category 2 storm. Winds from the north hit Santa Rosa and Escambia counties hardest, Insurance Journal reported.
As of Nov. 6, insurers had reported 68,071 claims and about $736 million in estimated losses, the Office of Insurance Regulation's table shows. That figure includes reserves for claims not yet paid, so it is not money paid out. Florida Phoenix and Insurance Journal reported the same totals.
Who's who: Yaworsky is Florida's insurance commissioner, and his office, the Office of Insurance Regulation, ordered the reporting on Oct. 12. AM Best is an insurance credit-rating firm. The American Property Casualty Insurance Association is the national insurers' trade group.
Why claims closed without payment
Of the 55,471 residential property claims, 12,996 had closed without payment by Nov. 6, or 23.4%, by our arithmetic. Of those, 6,569, about half, were below the deductible. For homeowners policies alone, 11,117 of 47,048 claims closed without payment, and 5,587 of those were below the deductible.
Across every line, auto included, 14,402 of the 68,071 claims closed without payment, about 21%. The state lists why: 6,835 below the deductible, 5,374 administrative, 1,864 for other exclusions or no policy in force, 326 for no flood coverage and three for fraud. All three fraud closures were auto claims. Administrative closures can include inquiries only, claims the owner withdrew, duplicates, wrong dates of loss and owners who stopped responding, the office says.
"Closed without payment" means the insurer found the claim not payable when it reported, the office says. It is not the same as a denial. Another 25,211 claims had closed with payment, 7,975 were open with payment and 20,482 were open with nothing paid yet; 58.2% of all claims had closed.
The count of no-payment closures has fallen. On Oct. 29 the News Service of Florida reported just over 15,000, against 14,402 on Nov. 6. The state has not said why.
About 21% of claims closed without payment, "about the same percentage seen in Sally," the 2020 hurricane, Insurance Journal reported. Sally drew almost 72,000 claims and $577 million in insured losses in the state's early count, and adjusted for inflation Sally's losses would be about the same as Isaias's, the outlet said. Modelers' industry-wide estimates are not comparable: Verisk puts insured onshore property losses from Isaias at $1 billion to $2 billion.
What a hurricane deductible costs
Florida law makes insurers that sell home policies offer hurricane deductibles of $500, 2%, 5% and 10% of the dwelling's insured value. On homes insured for $1 million to $3 million they may offer 3% in place of 2%, and at $3 million or more they need not offer 2%. The deductible applies once a calendar year to every hurricane claim with the same insurer or insurer group.
On a $1 million dwelling, a 3% deductible is $30,000, by our arithmetic. Insurers report $651 million in estimated residential losses on Isaias, reserves included.
Florida's market has changed since the 2022 and 2023 reforms
Since Florida's 2022 and 2023 property insurance reforms, 21 new companies have been approved to write home policies in the state, the regulator's July 2026 report says. Citizens Property Insurance Corp. had 266,231 policies on Aug. 31, 2026, down from a peak of 1.4 million in September 2023, its own count and the News Service of Florida show. In October, rate cuts of up to 12.1% took effect for more than 824,000 homeowners, the regulator says, and Yaworsky has said the market went from an F to a B, WFLX reported.
The October rate release did not mention Isaias. Florida still has the country's most expensive home insurance, at $8,471 a year for $300,000 of dwelling coverage, Insurance.com says.
Their side
Insurance agents and carriers have said most home damage from Isaias's 110-mph winds came from falling trees and limbs, Insurance Journal reported. The outlet also wrote that many owners withdrew claims once repair costs came in under their deductibles.
AM Best called Isaias an "earnings event" and expects little effect on insurers' surplus and overall financial soundness, per Insurance Journal. A Gallagher Re report said the storm was likely too small to move most carriers' reinsurance renewals, the outlet reported. Insurers are using all available resources to process Isaias claims, the American Property Casualty Insurance Association said, per Insurance Business.
What's next
What's next: Insurers keep reporting their Isaias claims to the state, and each update is cumulative. Separately, Florida Power & Light has asked state regulators for a temporary Isaias charge of $3.48 a month per 1,000 kilowatt-hours of home use, January through December 2027, a request still awaiting a decision, WEAR-TV and NBC6 report.
Sources we read
Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, Hurricane Isaias claims data, as of Nov. 6, 2026; data call notice, Oct. 12; Property Insurance Stability Report, July 1, 2026; rate release, Oct. 29; release, May 20. Florida Phoenix (Christine Sexton) via InsuranceNewsNet, Nov. 11. Insurance Journal, Nov. 9 and Nov. 10. Insurance Business, Oct. 12. News Service of Florida, Nov. 9, and via Florida Trend, Oct. 29, 2026 and Oct. 29, 2025. Claims Journal, Oct. 19. Artemis, Oct. 13. Florida Statutes s. 627.701. WFLX, April 17. WKMG News 6, Oct. 30. Citizens Property Insurance Corp., policies in force, Aug. 31. Insurance.com, Sept. 21. NBC6 Miami, Oct. 30. WEAR-TV, Nov. 2.
Disclosure
Disclosure: The publisher of Old Florida Money also runs a business that serves Florida property insurers.
Sources
- https://floir.gov/home/hurricane-isaias
- https://insurancenewsnet.com/oarticle/hurricane-isaias-claims-keep-climbing
- https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/southeast/2026/11/10/892259.htm
- https://www.insurancejournal.com/magazines/mag-features/2026/11/09/891558.htm
- https://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/us/news/catastrophe/insurers-mobilize-as-hurricane-isaias-loss-estimate-comes-in-at-23-billion-593232.aspx
- https://floir.gov/newsroom/archives/item-details/2026/10/12/data-call-notice-hurricane-isaias-catastrophe-reporting
- https://www.wflx.com/2026/04/17/florida-insurance-commissioner-says-market-rose-f-b-some-still-face-high-premiums/
- https://floir.gov/newsroom/archives/item-details/2026/05/20/insurance-commissioner-mike-yaworsky-announces-new-property---casualty-insurers--making-20-companies-entering-the-market-since-historic-legislative-reforms
- https://content.govdelivery.com/accounts/FLOIR/bulletins/430ec90
- https://www.clickorlando.com/news/florida/2026/10/30/florida-reveals-new-insurance-rate-drops-effective-this-month/
- http://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0600-0699/0627/Sections/0627.701.html
- https://www.floridatrend.com/articles/2026/10/29/federal-disaster-declared-isaias-insured-losses-grow/
- https://www.newsserviceflorida.com/townnews/meteorology/insured-losses-from-isaias-reach-735-million/article_295ca358-03dc-4774-87cd-09f40735e35b.html
- https://www.claimsjournal.com/news/national/2026/10/19/340792.htm
- https://www.artemis.bm/news/verisk-estimates-hurricane-isaias-insured-onshore-property-losses-in-1bn-to-2bn-range/
- https://www.nbcmiami.com/news/local/fpl-says-what-customers-could-pay-for-electricity-in-2027-lower-rate-but-a-new-charge/
- https://weartv.com/news/local/florida-power-light-seeks-psc-approval-for-temporary-isaias-restoration-surcharge
- https://www.citizensfla.com/-/20260831-policies-in-force
- https://www.floridatrend.com/articles/2025/10/29/citizens-policy-count-plummets/
- https://floir.gov/docs-sf/default-source/property-and-casualty/stability-unit-reports/july-2026-isu-report.pdf
- https://www.insurance.com/home-and-renters-insurance/home-insurance-unaffordable-states/
